Should You Attempt to Fix a Flat Tyre Yourself?

Getting a flat tyre is one of those situations that catches almost everyone off guard. You’re cruising along, maybe running late, and suddenly—thud thud thud. You pull over, check the damage, and yep… it’s flat. Now you’re faced with the question: Should I try to fix this myself or call for help?

If you’re like many drivers, you might feel torn. On one hand, changing a tyre seems like one of those “basic car things” everyone should know. On the other hand, it’s not always as simple as it sounds—and depending on the situation, trying to fix it yourself could do more harm than good.

So, let’s talk about it in real terms. When is it okay to roll up your sleeves and tackle that flat, and when is it smarter (and safer) to call in the pros?

When You Can Fix It Yourself

Let’s start with the good news: Yes, in some cases, changing a flat tyre is totally doable on your own—if you’ve got the right tools, the right conditions, and you know what you’re doing.

If the flat is from something like a nail or slow leak, and your vehicle is parked on a flat, stable surface away from traffic, you might be able to handle it. Here’s what you’ll need:

• A spare tyre (make sure it’s actually inflated!)
• Jack and wheel brace
• Your car’s manual (handy for jack points and tightening sequence)
• Some elbow grease

It’s even better if you’ve practised before or watched a step-by-step tutorial—not at the side of the road, but maybe in your driveway on a quiet Saturday.

But Here’s When You Shouldn’t Attempt It

Even if you know how to change a tyre, there are times when trying to do it yourself just isn’t worth the risk. Safety always comes first.

1. You’re on a busy road or highway
   Changing a tyre next to fast-moving traffic is extremely dangerous—even for experienced mechanics. If you’re on the shoulder of a freeway or a narrow road, it’s best to call roadside assistance or a tow truck. Your safety isn’t worth shaving 20 minutes off the clock.
2. The ground isn’t stable
   You can’t safely jack up your vehicle on uneven, sloped, sandy, or muddy surfaces. The car could slip or the jack could sink, putting you at serious risk of injury.
3. You’re not confident or physically able
   It’s okay to admit it: changing a tyre takes effort. The wheel nuts can be insanely tight, and lifting a tyre isn’t easy if you’re not used to it. Don’t risk hurting yourself—there’s no shame in calling for help.
4. You don’t have a usable spare
   Some newer cars don’t even come with a full-size spare tyre anymore. Run-flat tyres or tyre repair kits aren’t always enough for big punctures or sidewall damage.

Temporary Fixes: Sealants & Inflators

There are some quick-fix solutions like tyre sealant sprays or portable inflators. These can be useful if the puncture is small and you’re just trying to get to the nearest mechanic. But they’re temporary. And they won’t help if the tyre’s shredded, the valve’s broken, or the rim’s damaged.

So, use them as a last resort—not a long-term fix.

Real-World Example: When One Call Saved the Day

We once had a call from a driver in Melbourne’s eastern suburbs who tried to change a flat on a busy roadside after work. He was halfway through when a gust from a passing truck rocked the car and caused the jack to slip. Thankfully, he wasn’t underneath—but he was shaken, and the car was left sitting crooked with a half-loose wheel.

We arrived within 30 minutes, stabilised the vehicle, and safely swapped out the tyre. His tools were fine. His know-how was fine. But the location made it risky. That’s the thing—sometimes it’s not about skill, but about context.

So, Should You Fix It Yourself?

Here’s the takeaway:
If you’re in a safe location, have the right gear, and feel confident? Go for it. Changing your own tyre can save time and give you a sense of accomplishment.

But if you’re on a dangerous stretch of road, it’s dark, or something just feels off—play it safe. Call your roadside assistance provider or a local towing company (like us). That’s what we’re here for.

Flat tyres are annoying, but they don’t have to ruin your day. Whether you handle it yourself or let someone else take the reins, the goal is the same—getting you back on the road, safely.

 

If you are in Pakenham, and looking for a tow truck service, this is the best way to visit us.

Cranbourne Tow Trucks

39 S Gippsland Hwy, Cranbourne VIC 3977

(03) 7042 2059

info@cranbournetowtrucks.com.au